How Do Commercial Solicitors Help During a Business Dispute: 6 Steps Before You Ever Reach Court

Updated in November 2025

---

Commercial solicitors help during a business dispute by guiding you through six strategic steps before court: initial case assessment, sending a letter before action, pre-action protocol negotiations, exploring alternative dispute resolution like mediation, conducting settlement talks, and preparing litigation strategy as a last resort. This structured approach resolves 70 to 80 percent of UK business disputes without trial, typically within four to six weeks, and saves businesses between £15,000 and £180,000 in court costs while preserving valuable business relationships.

---

Table of Contents

1. What Is a Commercial Business Dispute and When Do You Need Legal Help?
2. Why Do Most Business Disputes Never Reach Court in the UK?
3. What Is the Pre-Action Protocol and Why Does It Matter?
4. The 6 Steps Commercial Solicitors Take Before Court
5. How Much Does It Cost to Use a Commercial Solicitor?
6. What Are the Top 10 Benefits of Resolving Disputes Before Court?
7. How Long Does Each Stage Take?
8. What Are the Latest Changes in 2025?
9. Common Questions Answered
10. Ready to Resolve Your Dispute?

What Is a Commercial Business Dispute and When Do You Need Legal Help?

A commercial business dispute happens when two or more parties in a business relationship disagree about contracts, payments, services, or obligations. Think unpaid invoices, broken contracts, partnership breakdowns, supplier problems, or intellectual property arguments.

Here’s the thing: not every disagreement needs a solicitor. If your supplier delivers products a day late and apologises, you probably don’t need legal help. But when the problem threatens your cash flow, reputation, or business relationships, that’s when you should pick up the phone.

When should you call a commercial solicitor?

You need legal help when:

• Someone owes you more than £5,000 and won’t pay
• A contract dispute threatens your business operations
• A business partner wants to leave or is breaching your agreement
• You’ve received a legal letter or threat of court action
• The other party has hired a solicitor
• You need to protect confidential information or trade secrets
• The dispute involves complex regulations or multiple parties

The earlier you get advice, the more options you have. Waiting until you’re served with court papers means you’ve already lost valuable time and negotiating power.

At Full Legal Business Solutions, we see business owners who wish they’d called six months earlier. Early intervention often means the difference between a quick settlement and a two-year court battle.

Why Do Most Business Disputes Never Reach Court in the UK?

Only about 5 to 10 percent of business disputes in England and Wales actually go to trial. The rest settle somewhere along the way. Why? Because going to court is expensive, slow, stressful, and public.

The real cost of litigation

Let’s talk numbers. A straightforward commercial dispute in the High Court costs between £20,000 and £100,000 in legal fees. Complex cases easily exceed £200,000. Then there’s the time: expect 12 to 24 months from issuing a claim to trial.

But money and time aren’t the only costs. Court proceedings are public record. Your competitors can read every detail. Your customers might see negative publicity. Business relationships get destroyed in the adversarial process.

What UK courts actually want

The Civil Procedure Rules, which govern all court cases in England and Wales, actively encourage alternatives to trial. Judges have the power to penalise parties who refuse reasonable settlement attempts, even if they win the case later.

According to GOV.UK guidance, courts expect parties to seriously consider alternative dispute resolution before issuing proceedings. Skip this step and you might pay the other side’s legal costs even if you’re in the right.

This isn’t just guidance. It’s a requirement. The courts are overwhelmed and want parties to solve problems themselves when possible.

What Is the Pre-Action Protocol and Why Does It Matter?

The pre-action protocol is a set of mandatory steps you must take before starting court proceedings. Think of it as the “try to sort this out first” rule baked into UK law.

What you must do before court

The Civil Procedure Rules require you to:

• Send a detailed letter before action to the other party
• Give them reasonable time to respond (usually 14 to 30 days)
• Exchange key information about the dispute
• Seriously consider alternative dispute resolution
• Try to narrow the issues between you

This isn’t optional. If you rush to court without following the protocol, the judge can order you to pay the other side’s costs. Even if you win your case.

Why this matters to your business

The pre-action protocol actually helps you. It forces both sides to lay their cards on the table early. Many disputes evaporate when people understand the full picture.

You might discover the other party has a valid defence you didn’t know about. Or they might realise your case is stronger than they thought and offer settlement. Either way, you save money by finding out early.

Our commercial litigation team helps businesses navigate these requirements properly. We’ve seen too many companies damage their position by sending aggressive letters that breach protocol or failing to engage when they should.

The 6 Steps Commercial Solicitors Take to Resolve Your Business Dispute Before Court

Now for the practical part. Here’s exactly what happens when you instruct a commercial solicitor to help with your dispute.

Step 1: Initial Case Assessment and Evidence Gathering

Your solicitor starts by understanding your situation completely. This means reviewing:

• All contracts and written agreements
• Email correspondence between parties
• Invoices, receipts, and financial records
• Any previous attempts to resolve the issue
• Relevant company documents or meeting minutes

Good solicitors ask tough questions at this stage. What’s your commercial objective? Is this about money, principle, or protecting future business? How much is the claim worth versus likely legal costs?

We evaluate your realistic prospects of success. If your case is weak, we’ll tell you. Honesty at this stage saves thousands later.

You’ll get clear advice on:

• Whether you have a valid legal claim or defence
• What evidence strengthens or weakens your position
• Estimated costs for each resolution pathway
• Realistic timeframes and outcomes

This initial consultation typically costs between £200 and £500, though many firms offer the first hour free. At Full Legal Business Solutions, we provide transparent cost estimates upfront so you can make informed decisions.

Step 2: Drafting and Sending the Letter Before Action

If proceeding makes commercial sense, your solicitor drafts a formal letter before action. This isn’t just “please pay up.” The letter must include specific information required by law:

• Full details of the claim, including dates and amounts
• The legal basis for your claim
• What you want the other party to do
• A reasonable deadline for response (typically 14 to 30 days)
• Clear statement that you’re following pre-action protocol
• Mention of your willingness to consider alternative dispute resolution

The tone matters. Aggressive, threatening letters often backfire. Professional, measured letters that demonstrate strength get better results.

Most disputes see movement after this letter. The other party might:

• Pay immediately
• Propose a payment plan
• Deny the claim with their reasons
• Make a counter-claim against you
• Ignore it completely (which strengthens your position later)

This step typically costs between £300 and £800 depending on complexity. It’s one of the best investments in dispute resolution because it often achieves settlement without further cost.

Step 3: Pre-Action Protocol Negotiations

Once letters are exchanged, the negotiation phase begins. Your solicitor acts as buffer and strategist, communicating with the other side to:

• Clarify misunderstandings
• Exchange additional documents
• Identify common ground
• Explore settlement options
• Narrow the issues in dispute

This phase can last two to eight weeks. Patience is crucial. Rushing to court shows weakness and costs you negotiating leverage.

Good negotiators know when to push and when to compromise. They understand your business objectives, not just your legal rights. Sometimes accepting 80 percent of what you’re owed makes more commercial sense than fighting for 100 percent.

Our dispute resolution experts have seen negotiations succeed at week seven after six weeks of apparent stalemate. The other side often needs time to investigate, get internal approval, or arrange finance.

Step 4: Exploring Alternative Dispute Resolution

If direct negotiations stall, the next step is formal alternative dispute resolution, or ADR. The two main types are mediation and arbitration.

Mediation involves a neutral third party helping both sides reach agreement. The mediator doesn’t make decisions but facilitates discussion. Sessions typically last one day and cost £500 to £3,000 total.

According to the Centre for Effective Dispute Resolution, 72 percent of commercial mediations settle on the day. Another 20 percent settle within weeks. That’s a 90 percent success rate overall.

Why does mediation work so well? Because it focuses on commercial interests, not legal rights. A judge can only award money. A mediator can help craft creative solutions: payment plans, replacement goods, future business arrangements, or mutual releases.

Arbitration is more formal. An arbitrator hears evidence from both sides and makes a binding decision, like a private judge. It costs more, between £5,000 and £50,000, and takes three to 12 months.

Arbitration suits disputes where:

• Technical expertise is needed
• Privacy is essential
• International parties are involved
• A binding decision is required

Your solicitor will advise which approach suits your situation. At Full Legal Business Solutions, we’re trained mediators and can guide you through either process.

Step 5: Conducting Formal Settlement Negotiations

Throughout the process, settlement discussions continue. These become more focused as each side understands the strength of their case.

One powerful tool is a Part 36 offer. This is a formal settlement offer made under special rules. If the other side rejects it and does worse at trial, they pay your costs from that point forward, even if they win overall.

Part 36 offers are tactical. Make one too early and you show weakness. Too late and it loses impact. Timing matters enormously.

Settlement negotiations might happen:

• Through solicitor correspondence
• At a formal mediation
• At the court door (literally minutes before trial)
• After a court has given initial directions

Most cases settle between weeks four and eight of the process. Both sides have assessed their positions and costs are starting to mount.

Your solicitor’s job is creating conditions that encourage settlement while maintaining pressure. This requires experience, judgment, and commercial awareness.

Step 6: Preparing Litigation Strategy (As Last Resort)

If everything else fails, litigation becomes necessary. But even at this stage, we’re preparing for two outcomes: trial or late settlement.

Preparation includes:

• Drafting detailed court statements
• Gathering and organising evidence
• Identifying and instructing expert witnesses
• Preparing witness statements
• Considering potential weaknesses in your case

The better prepared you are, the stronger your settlement position. Many cases settle after the other side sees your comprehensive preparation.

If you do go to trial, thorough preparation is essential. Cases are won or lost on evidence quality and presentation. Commercial Court judges are experienced and sharp. They spot weak cases quickly.

But here’s what most people don’t realise: even after issuing court proceedings, about 80 percent of cases still settle before trial. The litigation process itself often brings clarity that enables settlement.

How Much Does It Cost to Use a Commercial Solicitor for Business Disputes?

Let’s talk money. Legal costs worry every business owner, especially smaller companies.

Typical solicitor hourly rates in 2025

Commercial solicitors in the UK charge:

• Junior solicitors: £150 to £250 per hour
• Senior solicitors: £250 to £400 per hour
• Partners: £350 to £500 per hour
• London firms: Add 20 to 40 percent to these rates

Location matters. Middlesbrough and North East firms generally charge less than London or Manchester.

Cost comparison: Pre-court vs litigation

Here’s where it gets interesting. Let’s look at a typical £50,000 contract dispute:

Pre-court resolution:

• Initial advice and letter before action: £500 to £1,000
• Negotiation and correspondence: £1,000 to £2,000
• Mediation preparation and attendance: £1,500 to £3,000
• Total: £3,000 to £6,000

Full court litigation:

• Pre-trial work (statements, disclosure, witnesses): £15,000 to £40,000
• Court fees: £3,000 to £10,000
• Barrister fees: £5,000 to £30,000
• Expert witnesses: £3,000 to £15,000
• Trial (3 to 5 days): £10,000 to £30,000
• Total: £36,000 to £125,000

You can see why settling early makes commercial sense.

Can you recover legal costs?

Generally, yes, but not all of them. If you win at court, the losing party typically pays 60 to 70 percent of your reasonable costs. You’re still out of pocket for the rest.

But here’s the catch: if you refuse reasonable settlement offers or don’t engage with ADR, judges can order you to pay the other side’s costs even if you win.

Fixed fee and flexible options

Many solicitors offer fixed fees for specific stages:

• Initial consultation: Free to £500
• Letter before action: £500 to £800 fixed
• Mediation representation: £2,000 to £3,500 fixed

Some offer:

• Conditional fee agreements (no win, no fee) for strong cases
• Payment plans for ongoing work
• After-the-event insurance to cover opponent’s costs if you lose

Always get written cost estimates before instructing a solicitor. Ask about:

• Hourly rates for all people working on your case
• Estimated total costs for each stage
• What’s included and what’s extra (court fees, barrister fees, expert fees)
• How often you’ll receive cost updates

Our transparent pricing approach means no surprises. We provide detailed estimates and regular cost updates.

What Are the Top 10 Benefits of Resolving Business Disputes Before Court?

Why do we push so hard for pre-court resolution? Because the benefits are massive for most businesses.

1. Massive cost savings

ADR costs 70 to 90 percent less than full litigation. A £3,000 mediation beats a £40,000 trial every time.

2. Speed of resolution

Mediation takes four to six weeks. Court takes 12 to 24 months. That’s 10 to 20 months you’re not spending worrying about the case.

3. Relationship preservation

Court destroys business relationships. Mediation can preserve them. We’ve seen former adversaries continue trading after successful mediation.

4. Confidentiality

Court proceedings are public. Anyone can read them. ADR is private. Your competitors never know there was a problem.

5. Control over outcome

In court, a judge decides. In mediation, you decide. You can craft solutions that work for your business specifically.

6. Flexibility in solutions

Judges can only award money. Mediators can help you agree on payment plans, replacement goods, future discounts, mutual apologies, or continuing business relationships.

7. Reduced stress

Litigation is emotionally draining. The uncertainty, the adversarial nature, and the public process create enormous stress for business owners.

8. Business continuity

Less time fighting means more time running your business. Many business owners tell us litigation consumed 20 hours per week for months.

9. Higher success rates

Remember: 72 percent of mediations settle on the day. Court trials are unpredictable. You might lose a case you thought was strong.

10. Reputation protection

Public court battles damage reputations. Suppliers, customers, and partners see you as litigious. Private resolution protects your business image.

How Long Does Each Stage of Business Dispute Resolution Take?

Time is money. Let’s break down realistic timeframes for 2025.

Pre-action negotiations: 2 to 8 weeks

Letter before action, response, exchange of information, and initial negotiations typically take four to six weeks. Simple cases might resolve in two weeks. Complex disputes with multiple parties can take eight to ten weeks.

Mediation: 4 to 6 weeks total

From appointing a mediator to the actual session: four to six weeks. The session itself lasts six to eight hours (one day).

Arbitration: 3 to 12 months

Depends on complexity. Simple arbitrations take three to six months. International or multi-party disputes take 12 months or more.

Court proceedings: 12 to 24 months

From issuing the claim to trial:

• Fast track cases (under £25,000): 9 to 15 months
• Multi-track cases (over £25,000): 12 to 24 months
• Complex commercial cases: 18 to 36 months

Current Commercial Court lead times show trials being listed 12 to 18 months after case management conferences.

What delays matters?

Common delays include:

• Poor preparation or missing documents
• Parties not engaging promptly
• Need for expert evidence
• Court backlogs (still recovering from pandemic delays)
• Multiple parties with conflicting schedules
• Late disclosure of key documents

The lesson: engage early, prepare thoroughly, and respond promptly to all requests.

What Are the Latest Changes to UK Business Dispute Resolution in 2025?

The legal landscape keeps evolving. Here’s what’s new in 2025.

Increased court pressure on ADR

Courts are pushing harder than ever for parties to mediate. Recent cases show judges awarding costs penalties even against winning parties who unreasonably refused ADR.

One 2024 Court of Appeal case confirmed judges can order parties to attend mediation against their wishes in appropriate cases. This is a significant shift.

New costs budgeting procedures

From April 2025, Precedent Z simplifies costs budgeting for smaller cases. This means better cost control and more predictability for businesses with disputes under £250,000.

Changes to the Arbitration Act 1996

Proposed amendments include:

• New duties for arbitrators to disclose conflicts of interest
• Enhanced court powers to support emergency arbitrations
• Extended arbitrator immunity
• Simplified procedures for enforcement

These changes make arbitration more transparent and efficient for commercial disputes.

Technology in dispute resolution

Online dispute resolution platforms are growing. Some smaller claims now resolve entirely online without parties ever meeting.

Video mediation, which increased during COVID, is now standard. It reduces costs and makes mediation accessible to parties across the UK.

Focus on early intervention

The trend is clear: resolve disputes as early as possible. New protocols emphasise stocktaking exercises where parties review the dispute at key stages to identify settlement opportunities.

Growing ADR industry

More mediators, more training, and more specialisation mean better outcomes. Industry-specific mediators (construction, tech, healthcare) bring valuable expertise to commercial disputes.

At Full Legal Business Solutions, we’re staying ahead of these changes to give our clients every advantage.

Common Questions About Commercial Solicitors and Business Disputes

How much does a commercial solicitor cost for a business dispute in the UK?

Commercial solicitors typically charge £150 to £450 per hour depending on experience and location. For dispute resolution outside court, expect £2,000 to £5,000 for pre-action work and mediation. Full litigation costs £20,000 to £200,000 or more depending on complexity. Many firms offer free initial consultations and fixed fees for early-stage work.

Can business disputes be resolved without going to court?

Yes. Between 70 and 80 percent of UK business disputes resolve before trial through negotiation, mediation, or arbitration. The Civil Procedure Rules actually require parties to consider alternative dispute resolution before court. Pre-court methods are faster (4 to 6 weeks versus 12 to 18 months), cheaper, and often preserve business relationships better than litigation.

What is the pre-action protocol and why must I follow it?

The pre-action protocol is a mandatory set of steps under UK law before starting court proceedings. You must send a detailed letter before action, allow response time (typically 14 to 30 days), exchange key information, and seriously consider ADR. Failing to comply can result in cost penalties even if you win later, as courts expect reasonable settlement attempts first.

When should I hire a commercial solicitor for a business dispute?

Hire a solicitor early, ideally as soon as a serious dispute emerges or before sending formal communications. Early intervention helps preserve evidence, avoid costly mistakes, and often resolves disputes faster and cheaper. Solicitors prevent you breaching pre-action protocol rules or missing critical time limits (typically six years for contract disputes in England and Wales).

What’s the difference between mediation and arbitration for business disputes?

Mediation uses a neutral facilitator to help parties negotiate their own settlement. It’s voluntary, non-binding unless agreed, and costs £500 to £3,000. Arbitration is more formal. An arbitrator makes a legally binding decision like a judge, costs £5,000 to £50,000 or more, and takes three to 12 months. Mediation preserves relationships better. Arbitration provides certainty when agreement is impossible.

Is it worth fighting a business dispute or should I just pay?

Don’t automatically pay, but don’t fight purely on principle either. Assess commercially: what’s the financial exposure, what are legal costs versus potential recovery, and what’s the reputational impact? A good solicitor helps you make a business decision, not an emotional one. Sometimes strategic settlement is wisest. Sometimes robust defence protects your business long-term. Get proper advice early.

Ready to Resolve Your Business Dispute Without the Courtroom Drama?

Business disputes drain time, money, and energy. But as we’ve seen, most resolve without ever seeing a courtroom. The six-step approach we’ve outlined gives you a clear roadmap from initial problem to final resolution.

The key is acting early. Every week you delay costs you negotiating power and increases legal expenses. The sweet spot is week one to three after the problem emerges. That’s when your options are widest and costs lowest.

Remember these key points:

• Follow the pre-action protocol to avoid cost penalties
• Consider mediation seriously – it works in 72 percent of cases
• Get proper advice before sending angry letters or making threats
• Think commercially, not emotionally
• Preserve evidence from day one
• Calculate the true cost of litigation before committing to court

At Full Legal Business Solutions in Middlesbrough, we’ve helped hundreds of North East businesses resolve commercial disputes efficiently. Most settle within six to eight weeks for a fraction of litigation costs.

We offer a free initial consultation where we’ll give you honest advice about your situation. Sometimes that means telling you that you don’t need a solicitor. Other times it means outlining a clear strategy to resolve your dispute quickly.

Don’t let a business dispute become a business disaster. The sooner you act, the more options you have. Call us today or visit our website to book your free consultation.

Most clients tell us they wish they’d called sooner. Don’t make that mistake.